Next Week's Flavors

The all-time leaderboard

Best Crumbl Cookies of All Time, Ranked by Real Ratings

The best-rated Crumbl cookie right now is the Chocolate Chip Cookie: 4.70 stars from 2,835 ratings on Crumbl.

Updated Oct 12, 2026 · By CrumbleDrop · How we rank

13Flavors ranked
1.1MRatings counted on Crumbl
1Reader ratings on CrumbleDrop
1Best ratedCookie Chocolate Chip Cookie 4.70★★★★★ 2,835 ratings on Crumbl 2Runner-upBrownie Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie ft. REESE’S PIECES 4.57★★★★★ 16,749 ratings on Crumbl 3ThirdCookie Raspberry Cheesecake 4.56★★★★★ 67,371 ratings on Crumbl

Every flavor, ranked

The full Crumbl cookie ranking

Ranked by Crumbl customers

Ranked by Crumbl customers' star ratings, copied from Crumbl on Oct 12, 2026. A flavor needs 1,000+ ratings on Crumbl to qualify. These are Crumbl's numbers, not our readers'.

Ranked by Crumbl rating, 1,000+ ratings on Crumbl to qualify. Ties go to the flavor with more ratings.
RankFlavorCrumbl ratingRatingsCategoryLast on the menuSummary
1 Chocolate Chip CookieCookieAlways on the menu 4.70★★★★★ 2,835 Chocolate Always on the menu Chocolate · 2,835 ratings · Always on the menu
2 Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie ft. REESE’S PIECESBrownie 4.57★★★★★ 16,749 Peanut Butter Oct 2026 Peanut Butter · 16,749 ratings · Oct 2026
3 Raspberry CheesecakeCookie 4.56★★★★★ 67,371 Fruit Oct 2026 Fruit · 67,371 ratings · Oct 2026
4 White Drop Cookie ft. HERSHEY’S Cookies ‘n’ CremeCookie 4.56★★★★★ 25,260 Other Oct 2026 Other · 25,260 ratings · Oct 2026
5 Halloween Confetti Milkshake CookieCookie 4.55★★★★★ 16,542 Seasonal Oct 2026 Seasonal · 16,542 ratings · Oct 2026
6 Snickerdoodle CookieCookie 4.53★★★★★ 179,324 Vanilla Oct 2026 Vanilla · 179,324 ratings · Oct 2026
7 Biscoff® Crunch BrownieBrownie 4.53★★★★★ 25,436 Chocolate Oct 2026 Chocolate · 25,436 ratings · Oct 2026
8 Pink Sugar CookieCookieAlways on the menu 4.48★★★★ 259,287 Vanilla Always on the menu Vanilla · 259,287 ratings · Always on the menu
9 Cinnamon Roll CookieCookie 4.47★★★★ 112,146 Vanilla Oct 2026 Vanilla · 112,146 ratings · Oct 2026
10 Biscoff® Ice Cream CookieCookie 4.47★★★★ 81,397 Caramel Oct 2026 Caramel · 81,397 ratings · Oct 2026
11 Caramel Shortbread Cookie ft. TWIX®Cookie 4.28★★★★ 149,032 Caramel Oct 2026 Caramel · 149,032 ratings · Oct 2026
12 Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie ft. OREO®Cookie 4.22★★★★ 44,904 Peanut Butter Oct 2026 Peanut Butter · 44,904 ratings · Oct 2026
13 Pumpkin Chocolate Chip CookieCookie 4.13★★★★ 76,922 Seasonal Oct 2026 Seasonal · 76,922 ratings · Oct 2026

Ranked by CrumbleDrop readers

Ranked by ratings from CrumbleDrop readers. A flavor needs 5+ reader ratings to qualify.

No flavor has 5 reader ratings yet. Rate the cookies you have tried on their flavor pages and this board fills in.

Not ranked yet: under 1,000 Crumbl ratings

Best in each category

The top-rated Crumbl cookie in every category

One winner per category from the Crumbl customers' ranking.

Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookie4.70 on Crumbl · 3k ratings Peanut Butter Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie ft. REESE’S PIECES4.57 on Crumbl · 17k ratings Fruit Raspberry Cheesecake4.56 on Crumbl · 67k ratings Other White Drop Cookie ft. HERSHEY’S Cookies ‘n’ Creme4.56 on Crumbl · 25k ratings Seasonal Halloween Confetti Milkshake Cookie4.55 on Crumbl · 17k ratings Vanilla Snickerdoodle Cookie4.53 on Crumbl · 179k ratings Caramel Biscoff® Ice Cream Cookie4.47 on Crumbl · 81k ratings

The bottom of the board

The worst-rated Crumbl cookies

The five lowest-rated flavors among those with 1,000+ ratings on Crumbl.

No. 13 of 13Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookie 4.13 ★★★★ 76,922 ratings Numbers only: we have not tasted this one yet. No. 12 of 13Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie ft. OREO® 4.22 ★★★★ 44,904 ratings Numbers only: we have not tasted this one yet. No. 11 of 13Caramel Shortbread Cookie ft. TWIX® 4.28 ★★★★ 149,032 ratings Numbers only: we have not tasted this one yet. No. 10 of 13Biscoff® Ice Cream Cookie 4.47 ★★★★ 81,397 ratings Numbers only: we have not tasted this one yet. No. 9 of 13Cinnamon Roll Cookie 4.47 ★★★★ 112,146 ratings Numbers only: we have not tasted this one yet.

How we rank

Three sources, shown apart, never mixed

Every number on this page says where it came from. We never blend sources into one score, never put Crumbl's numbers in search markup, and never delete a low rating.

1

Crumbl customers

The star rating and rating count Crumbl shows for each flavor, copied by hand and dated.

  • Qualifies at 1,000+ ratings
  • Ties go to the flavor with more ratings
  • Updated every week for the flavors on the menu
2

CrumbleDrop readers

Ratings left on our flavor pages. One per person per flavor, removed only for spam or abuse.

  • Qualifies at 5+ ratings
  • Low ratings are never removed
  • Shown as its own ranking, never mixed with Crumbl's
3

Our tasting

Our own verdict, only for cookies someone at CrumbleDrop actually ate.

  • Marked "We tasted it" in the ranking
  • Never used to reorder the ranking
  • Full verdicts live on each flavor page

Full method: How we review. CrumbleDrop is independent and not affiliated with Crumbl.

Questions

Best Crumbl cookie FAQ

What is the best Crumbl cookie of all time?

By Crumbl customers' ratings it is the Chocolate Chip Cookie, at 4.70 stars from 2,835 ratings on Crumbl (copied Oct 12, 2026).

What is the most popular Crumbl flavor?

The Pink Sugar Cookie, with 259,287 ratings on Crumbl, the most of any flavor we track. It is always on the menu, which is part of why.

What is the worst-rated Crumbl cookie?

Among flavors with 1,000+ ratings on Crumbl, the Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Cookie is lowest at 4.13 stars from 76,922 ratings.

How is this ranking made?

From Crumbl customers' star ratings, copied from Crumbl and dated, with 1,000+ ratings needed to qualify. Ratings from CrumbleDrop readers are ranked separately and never blended in.

This week's Crumbl menu, rated Every Crumbl flavor ever Next week's flavors