A soft sugar cookie brushed with a milky glaze and topped with Fruity PEBBLES cereal, built to taste like cereal milk.
The Cereal Milk Cookie ft. Fruity PEBBLES™ is a soft sugar cookie built around the taste of the milk left in a cereal bowl. Crumbl brushes it with a milky glaze and covers the top in Fruity PEBBLES cereal.
Crumbl lists it at 680 calories for the whole cookie. One detail worth knowing before you order: Crumbl’s allergen chart lists tree nuts for this cookie, and says it may contain soy and peanut.
We have not tasted it yet. Our notes, photos and score go up after tasting day.
How Crumbl builds it, top to bottom. Our own close-up photos join this section after tasting day.
Built from Crumbl's own description. The bands use this cookie's colour, from light at the top to deep at the base.
Our order-or-skip call goes up once we have tasted it. Until then, here are the three ratings we track, always kept apart.
Our score
Tasting this week
Out of 5, after we taste it
Crumbl rating
4.18
★★★★140,627 ratings on Crumbl
| Fat | 30 g | |
|---|---|---|
| Carbs | 96 g | |
| Sugar | 64 g | |
| Protein | 7 g |
Whole item, from Crumbl's published figures. The ring shows the share of a 2,000-calorie day. Bars compare each amount with its daily value (fat 78 g, carbs 275 g, protein 50 g; sugar against the 50 g added-sugar value).
Full-size calories Crumbl listed for that week's items and the two classics.
Quick answers from Crumbl’s own published figures, with the date we checked them.
The whole Cereal Milk Cookie ft. Fruity PEBBLES is 680 calories, according to Crumbl (checked Oct 19, 2026), with 30 g fat, 96 g carbs, 64 g sugar and 7 g protein.
Crumbl’s allergen chart lists tree nuts for it, along with milk, egg and wheat, and says it may contain soy and peanut (Lubbock, TX store, checked Oct 19, 2026). The chart does not name the nut, so ask your store if that matters to you.
Yes. Crumbl’s Lubbock, TX store listed a mini version on Oct 19, 2026, with the same allergens as the full size.
